Dr. David Scheiner, who treated the president for over 20 years, says Obama’s plan will fail because it doesn’t go far enough:
The man Barack Obama consulted on medical matters for over two decades said on Tuesday that the president’s vision for health care reform is bound for failure.
Dr. David Scheiner, a 70-year Chicago-based physician who treated Obama for more than 20 years, said he was disheartened by the health care legislation his former patient is championing, calling it piecemeal and ineffectual.
“I look at his program and I can’t see how it’s going to work,” Scheiner told the Huffington Post. “He has no cost control. There would be no effective cost control in his program. The [Congressional Budget Office] said it’s going be incredibly expensive … and the thing that I really am worried about is, if it is the failure that I think it would be, then health reform will be set back a long, long time.”
[…]
“His pragmatism is what is overwhelming him.” Scheiner added: “I think he’s afraid that he can’t get anything through if he doesn’t go through this incredibly compromised program.”
Admitting that he was not a political practitioner, Scheiner said he felt compelled to speak out because of his unique relationship with the president and this critical moment in the health care debate. A champion of a single-payer health care system, Scheiner noted repeatedly that he came to the debate from the perspective of having dealt with the hassles and pitfalls of the current system. His speaking out is part of a larger effort, launched by Physicians for a National Health Program, to push Congress to consider single-payer as an alternative to current reform proposals.
As Scheiner sees it, all alternatives simply fall short. Keeping private insurers in the market, he warns, would simply maintain burdensome administrative costs. He argued further that the pharmaceutical industry is not being asked to make “any kind of significant sacrifices” in the current round of reform negotiations. As for a public health care option, Scheiner insists that the proposal remains vague and inadequate.
The conservative reaction to this revelation is (predictably) going to fall into one of two categories. In the first category are those who will ignore (or stop before reading) the part where Dr. Scheiner advocates a single-payer Medicare-style system in order to claim “Even B. Hussein Osama X The Usurper’s doctor thinks he’s too much of a socialist-commie-fascist for ‘Murka!!!111!1!1!1!!!1!eleventy-one!” These people will be aided and abetted by lazy mooks in the corporate media like Forbes’ David Whelan, whose article on the subject buries the lede — Dr. Scheiner’s support for a single-payer health care system — so far down that you have to have specialized equipment to find it. Whelan further compounds his sins with the article’s deceptive title, “Obama’s Doctor Knocks ObamaCare,” which hits all the talking points the intellectually dishonest cadre of the conservative punditocracy will jump all over like flies on shit. For all its sins, though, Whelan’s article does contain one interesting, if potentially worrisome note:
[Dr. Scheiner] supports the idea of that option for people who don’t like or can’t afford their HMO. But he worries that it will be watered down or not happen at all. “It’s nonsense that the private insurance companies need to be protected,” he says. “Why? Because they’ve done such a good job?”
Indeed.
The second class of conservative reaction to this story will come from those who are intellectually honest enough to admit that Obama’s doctor is disappointed with the truncated scope of Obama’s plan, but will use it to bash Dr. Scheiner as some sort of commie socialist-fascist poopyhead. Considering the decidedly anti-intellectual bent of today’s conservative movement, the proportion of conservative pundits who will likely fall into this category is considerably smaller, but definitely nonzero.
TALK ABOUT PRESCIENT: It appears that Dr. Scheiner’s fear mentioned in the deceptive David Whelan article has come to pass.
Blue Dogs Delay, Water Down House Health Care Bill

What was it that Bartcop said?
How did I get in a party of gutless wankers?
We need to get us some new, better Democrats. Preferably ones with actual, functioning spines.